Links List 11.14.08
November 14th, 2008by Sean Gorman
The Google GEO APIs team developed a KML Interactive Sampler page. Now people, who want to learn KML, can learn by examples. The Sampler page uses the Google Earth Plugin to demonstrate various features while displaying KML code.
Next week, George Mason University and the University of Virginia are celebrating GIS Day(s). They invite the general public to their GIS festivities. GMU’s featured speakers include Carmel Menzel, ESRI and Justin Procopio, National Geographic Society. David Rumsey, an expert on historical maps, will speak at UVA’s GIS Day.
The Google Maps API terms of service is causing the Ordnance Survey grief. The OS was unhappy with local authorities signing up to the Google Maps API terms of service as it required a “broad” re-licensing of the data to Google and the users of Google maps based sites. According to the OS, Show Us a Better Way broke copyright regulations by embedding info on Google Maps that was “derived” from OS data. Yesterday, Google released an updated Terms of Service for both Google Maps and Earth. For OS’ sake, the new published terms should help solve this issue.
Google announced the Google Geo Challenge Grants. The challenge encourages organizations, especially non-profits, to use maps as mediums to communicate issues and implement plans. The grants range from US$5,000 and US$100,000. For more the challenge guidelines, visit the Geo Challenge page.
Yesterday was “Make Slashgeo Known to the Community Day!” We encourage our readers to also show their support for our fellow GeoFriend!
Popularity: 16% [?]
Flash vs. Javascript for Web Mapping Applications: Our Experience with Maker!
October 22nd, 2008by Sean Gorman
There has been an interesting discussion going over on James Fee’s blog on the merits of ESRI’s new javascript API and Flex API. James has thrown his lot in with the JavaScript API, and a host of Flex/Flash developers have been exposing their technology’s merits. While we don’t use either of ESRI’s APIs internally we did have to make a choice between Flash and JavaScript/HTML when we were developing Maker. At the end of the day we ended up blending the two approaches - implementing JavaScript where it made sense and utilizing Flash when we needed powerful vector rendering capabilities.
One of the most useful references for me in this process was a workshop Tom Carden gave at ETech last year on the data rendering capabilities of a variety of approaches. The readers digest version of the workshop went something along these lines:
HTML/Javascript - handles 100-1000 data points - loads in .1 seconds
Flash - handles up to 10,000 data points - loads in 1 second
Java/Processing - handles up to 100,000 points - loads in 10 seconds
OpenGL - handles upwards of 1,000,000 points - loads in 100 seconds
For Maker we wanted to be able to handle 10,000+ points/polygons and there was no way JavaScript was going to be able to handle it. Of course rendering the data was just one of many problems. Not only did we have to render the data but also parse it from the server out to the client while running the mathematical operation enabling you to take advantage of the structured data being sent. The team came with lots of clever tricks to pull it off, but the level of performance afforded by using Flash for rendering the vector data was not available with JavaScript. Processing could be a very cool option as the technology matures. Silverlight could also be a great option if they can get the plug-in universally embedded into browsers as with Flash.
While Flash was a great option for the tiling and vector rendering we did not want to build out the entire application in Flash for a variety of reasons. In GeoCommons everything outside of the map itself is JavaScript/HTML. This is probably rudimentary for many folks, but reading the debate on James’ blog I think sometimes developers lose sight of picking the best tool for the job. Oftentimes it is easy to get wedded to an approach just because it is what you know well. We were complete Flash rookies when we started, but got some great help from Tom with Modest Maps, Axis Maps with the Flash development and cartography, hired some full time resources, and learned a lot on our own. It ended up being a great approach for the specific problems we were facing. As long as you are using standard interfaces in your development, you should be able to fluidly adapt to the technology that makes the most sense for your set of problems.
Popularity: 26% [?]
Off the Map Presents Top 25 Blogs in GIS, GeoWeb and Cartography
September 9th, 2008by Sean Gorman
*Post updated at 2:00 PM, September 9, 2008 to reflect blogs we missed. Our next edition will include ONLY the top 25 blogs, but we wanted to keep all on the original list from this week.*
Here at Off the Map we’re always interested in what bloggers have to say about new technologies and services in GIS and on the GeoWeb. With our interest in cartography through the development of Maker!, we’ve broadened the categories beyond just GIS and GeoWeb blogs.
We decided to have a little fun and do a friendly ranking of some relevant blogs. The Top 25 Blogs in GIS, GeoWeb and Cartography will be ranked according to the number of sites/blogs linking to each, as reported by Technorati. If a blog does NOT have Technorati Authority (if they have not registered for example), then we’ll take the number of blog reactions listed and divide by 3 for an estimate.
We realize Technorati is not a perfect barometer, but it is open, and this is not a FortiusOne subjective ranking. We think this will be a great way to share blogs and get feedback from others regarding their top GIS, GeoWeb and cartography blog picks. We’ll note changes in rankings, new blogs and up and coming blogs.
If you’re on the list and feel so inclined, you’re welcome to place the following badge on your blog to share your ranking.

Our first ranking follows. We’ll be updating the list bi-weekly and note changes in ranking and inbound links. Since we’re only doing a Top 25 list, we’d like to give a shout out to some other great blogs out there such as Indiemaps and Cartogrammer. If there is another blog you feel should be included, please let us know!
- O’Reilly Radar Geo Blog 2,733 – overall O’Reilly (5 Blog reactions for Geo Blog)
- Strange Maps 1,895
- Google Earth Blog 950
- Google Maps Mania 553
- Ogle Earth 186
- All Points Blog (Directions Magazine) 176
- James Fee GIS Blog — Blogging GIS, Google Earth, Virtual Earth and Programming 156
- The Map Room: A weblog about maps 139
- The Beer Mapping Project 91
- Geobloggers 73
- Mapperz 72
- Very Spatial (Blog and Podcast) 66
- Bret Taylor’s Blog 64 (estimate based on 195 Blog Reactions)
- Mibazaar 61
- Dave Bouwman - GIS Blogs: Where’s the Conversation? 53
- Ed Parsons 52
- What is so special about Geospatial? 52
- Chris Spagnulo’s Geoscrum 51
- AnyGeo - Anything Geospatial 46
- Mandown 35
- The Earth Is Square 35
- Mapdango 34
- GIS Lounge 31
- Mapping Hacks 28
- Geography Matters – Est. 27 (based on 83 blog reactions)
- Geospatial Semantic Web 26
- Vector One 26
- Computing, GIS and Archeology in the UK 23
- GeoNames Blog 18
- GeoMusings 14
- Slashgeo 14
- Geocarta 12
- Webmapper 10
- Sean Gillies 10
- Indiemaps 8
- Cartogrammer 7
- Geography 2.0 2
Popularity: 60% [?]
Links List 8.15.08
August 15th, 2008by Sean Gorman
Yahoo officially opened their experimental geo-location platform, Fire Eagle, to everyone on Tuesday. The location management service enables users to post their positional data on the web. One of the notable features is privacy. Although users are sharing their location, they can set limitations on what location information can be released. Pownce, Movable Type and Outside.in are the three companies currently using the service.
Photo host Flickr announced a new addition to their existing features: geotagging. Users can now drag their photos to a Yahoo Map through a link provided in their profile. Flickr will still offer Organizr, and highly recommends using that tool for batch geotagging. The new feature will be used to easily tag single photos. Check out this link that has Beijing Flickr photos on top of OpenStreetMap based data. Interestingly, the base Yahoo map for Beijing has hardly any road data and no street names.
Russia-Georgia’s war has been mapped. The CatholicGauze has been keeping track of the battle locations as the war progresses. Both Google Maps and Live Maps are covering the battle areas, even though Google has been called out for not finding the correct data for regions in Georgia.
A post from Sean Gillies asks for distinction between “web GIS” and “Geoweb”. James Fee and Andrew commented on the post, saying that “WebGIS” is tools and technology while “geoweb” is a whole other “social web”.
Popularity: 12% [?]





